1938 Carnegie Tech (PA) *
1966 Wilkes (PA)
1968 Wilkes (PA)
1970 Edinboro (PA)
1972

Franklin & Marshall (PA)

.. ..
1974 Ithaca (NY)
1976 C.W. Post (NY)
1978 Ithaca (NY)
1980 Widener (PA)
1982 Tie Plymouth State (NH) & St. Lawrence (NY)
.. ..
1984 Tie IIthaca (NY) & Union (NY)
1986 Salisbury (MD)
1088 Ithaca (NY)
1990 Allegheny (PA)
1992 Washington & Jefferson (PA)
.. ..
1994 Washington & Jefferson (PA)
1996 Rowan (NJ)
1998 Rowan (NJ)
2000 Widener (PA)
2002 SUNY-Brockport (NY)
.. ..
2004 Rowan (NJ)
2006 St. John Fisher (NY)
2008 Wesley (DE)
2010 Wesley (DE)
2012 Hobart (NY)
.. ..
2014 Wesley (DE)
2016 Alfred (NY)
2018 ..
2020 ..
2022 ..
.. ..
1966
Gettysburg (PA) **
1967 Wagner (NY)
1969 USMMA - King's Point (NY)
1971 Alfred (NY)
1973 C.W. Post (NY)
.. ..
1975 Ithaca (NY)
1977 Westminster (PA)
1979 Carnegie Mellon (PA)
1981 Plymouth State (NH)
1983 Hofstra (NY)
.. ..
1985 Ithaca (NY)
1987 Wagner (NY)
1989 Union (NY)
1991 Ithaca (NY)
1993 Rowan (NJ)
.. ..
1995 Rowan (NJ)
1997 Lycoming (PA)
1999 Rowan (NJ)
2001 Rowan (NJ)
2003 Rensselaer Poly (NY)
.. ..
2005 Rowan (NJ)
2007 Wesley (DE)
2009 Wesley (DE)
2011 Wesley (DE)
2013 St. John Fisher (NY)
..
..
2015 Wesley (DE)
2017

SUNY-Brockport (NY)..

2019 ..
2021 .
2023 ..
..
..
Editor's Note - * Carnegie Tech (PA) , now named Carnegie Mellon (PA) is the only D-III program to ever win the Lambert Trophy, claiming the 1938 award --- ** Gettysburg (PA) was the recipient of the 1966 Lambert FCS Cup while the same year, Wilkes (PA) won the inaugural Lambert D-III Cup